Sugar Babies Candy: What’s Really Inside This Classic Treat?

Sugar Babies — the chewy caramel candy that’s been around for decades — is a favorite in movie theaters and nostalgic candy aisles. But if you’re wondering what’s actually inside that shiny yellow box… you’re not alone. Let’s break down what Sugar Babies candy is made of — and what you might want to think about before unwrapping the next one.
June 30, 2025
✅ Fact checked
July 1, 2025

What’s in Sugar Babies candy?

Sugar Babies are caramel-coated milk candies, with a soft, chewy texture that sticks around (literally).

Here’s what’s typically in the ingredients list:

  • Sugar

  • Corn syrup

  • Hydrogenated oils

  • Dextrose

  • Artificial flavors and coloring

  • Milk solids and whey

So yes — they’re loaded with sugar and ultra-processed additives. That doesn’t mean you can’t enjoy them ever again, but they definitely fall into the “occasional treat” category.

Why the problem goes beyond sugar

The issue with Sugar Babies — and many candies like them — isn’t just the sugar. It’s the combination of:

  • Processed sweeteners like corn syrup and dextrose

  • Hydrogenated oils (which can contribute to inflammation)

  • Artificial additives that don’t offer any nutritional benefit

These ingredients make the product shelf-stable, addictive, and very hard to stop eating once you start.

So… are Sugar Babies “bad” for you?

It depends on how often you’re eating them. A few pieces now and then? Not a big deal. But like all ultra-processed sweets, they should be treated as occasional indulgences, not everyday snacks.

And if you’re trying to build healthier habits or avoid blood sugar spikes, there are better choices out there — or at least better ways to enjoy sweet things without overdoing it.

Download the app

GoCoCo helps you spot what the label doesn’t say

Most candy brands won’t tell you they’re ultra-processed — and many people don’t realize how much added sugar or low-quality fats are hidden in some snacks.

That’s why we created GoCoCo. With just a scan, you can:

  • 📱 Get a health score based on ingredients, not just calories

  • 🚫 Identify ultra-processed foods with red flags for sugar, emulsifiers, and additives

  • 🍫 Compare sweet options to find treats with cleaner, simpler ingredients

  • 🎯 Build habits that focus on balance — not restriction

Want something sweet? Try these instead

Looking for better-for-you alternatives that still satisfy your sweet tooth?

Here are a few ideas:

  • Frozen banana slices dipped in dark chocolate

  • Medjool dates with almond butter

  • Oat balls with cocoa and peanut butter

  • A square of 70% dark chocolate (just one!)

🥄 Portion tip: Stick to a few bites or a small handful — not the whole box.

Sugar Babies candy is exactly what it says on the box — sugar, sugar, and more sugar. If you love them, enjoy them occasionally. But if you want to snack smarter without giving up sweet things, GoCoCo helps you scan, compare, and build better habits that actually stick.

FAQS

Are Sugar Babies ultra-processed?
Yes — they contain corn syrup, hydrogenated oils, and artificial flavors and colors.
Can I eat Sugar Babies if I’m managing blood sugar?
It’s best to enjoy them occasionally and pair with fiber or fat to reduce blood sugar impact.
What’s a better alternative to Sugar Babies?
Try whole food-based treats like dates with nut butter or dark chocolate — and scan options with GoCoCo.

Download GoCoCo
food tracker & product scanner

🥗 Use the GoCoCo App to scan and identify healthier foods effortlessly. Get the app now!
Download
>>

Orzo pasta is not gluten free but there are alternatives. Learn what orzo is made of, what to avoid, and how to choose better options for a balanced plate.

Gluten Free Orzo: What You Need to Know

Hy-Vee Whipped Cream Cheese contains emulsifiers. Learn how to enjoy it mindfully and what to choose instead with GoCoCo.

Is Hy-Vee Whipped Cream Cheese Healthy?

Peanut butter is naturally gluten free but some brands carry cross-contamination risks. Here’s how to check the label and choose wisely.

Is Peanut Butter Gluten Free?